When "who" is the object of the preposition, as in this case, it becomes "whom"; granted, this is archaic and often ignored in informal conversation. You'll often hear people say things like, "Who should I give this to?" It would be correct to say "Whom should I give this to?" or even (if you're really fussy) "To. You can certainly ask Whom are you hanging out with?— it's completely grammatical— though the kind of person who would say it would probably use the even more stilted With whom are you hanging out? The difference between who and whom has been covered extensively in previous questions. Whom. Dear English speakers, how would you ask "who did you speak with?" or "whom did you speak with?". Is there any rule about using "who" or "whom"?There are people (with) whom I feel comfortable (with.
Congratulations to all the winners, most of whom are definitely reading this blog! What's 'stilted' about 'with whom'? Here's how it works: And, since accusative and dative forms both look like whom , you know it should always be whom if you are using whom at all. The Millennium Stadium accommodates 72, spectators, all of whom are seated.
With whom - totally
To me, it doesn't sound good to use whom at the start of a relative clause with a stranded preposition. However, it's not the only way, or necessarily the best way of expressing this idea. The use of the relative pronoun who is wrong!!!! If it is, is with always a dative preposition like mit in German? There is nothing incorrect with the answer given by Anderson Silva. If I wanted to use whom, I would prefer to use pied-piping as well, as in sentence 2. The downvote was given because I suspect some people don't regard "Grammar Girl" to be an authoritative voice. But German has some genitive prepositions that definitely aren't genitive in English, so you can't trust those. Here are some Language Log links I found that feature some nuanced discussion of the matter; as far as I can tell, the first doesn't recommend using "whom" in these circumstances, and the second only recommends it with tongue firmly in cheek: I read about "whom" but it isn't very common, is it? Note that there are not nearly as many inflectional changes or pronoun substitutions in English as in German. The Millennium Stadium accommodates 72, spectators, all of whom are seated. According to the rules of formal grammar, who should be used in the subject position in a sentence, while whom should be used in the object position, and also after a preposition. Here is a really easy way to deal with case and prepositions: Unfortunately, you seem to undermine his comment a bit though Okay, I'm confussed and a little bit dizzy Thanks. Who is walking whom? I actually would call it ungrammatical, although some people might disagree with me about that see Janus Bahs Jacquet's comment on the following post: Your email address will not be published. We ask "Who did you talk with?
With whom Video